Call

Welcome to The Not Perfect Cookie Co.

Custom sugar cookies in Lafayette, Indiana

I don't promise perfection, but I do promise DELICIOUS, beautifully decorated sugar cookies for any occasion!

rainbow sprinkles in a glass bowl

Who wants COOKIES?!?!

Have an event coming up?  Need a delicious sweet treat to share with your guests?  I can make cookies for just about any occasion (even if you just want the cookies for yourself - no one said you have to share!).  I would love to work with you to create the (not) perfect show-stopping dessert!  Contact me and let's get started!

Baby showers, weddings, birthdays, graduations, sports teams, bridal showers, bachelor/bachelorette parties, anniversaries, retirements, and more!  

Meet Your Baker

Hi!  I'm Lindsey Huffman!

I've been decorating cookies for fun for almost two years now, but decided to start my own business in November 2023.  I specialize in vanilla-almond sugar cookies with royal icing, but I can work with you to create your (not) perfect cookies!

I graduated from Lafayette Jefferson High School and Indiana University. My background is in marketing, but I've always had a passion for art. I love decorating cookies because it's a great artistic outlet for me, plus, PEOPLE LOVE COOKIES!!

Custom, hand-decorated cookies

I'd love to create amazing edible art for you!

Whatever your vision, I can probably bring it to life!

Getting Married?

Cookies are the "new cake"

No one says you have to serve cake at your wedding! I can create a custom set of cookies for your guests to enjoy!